Reasons For The Rejection Of A Research Paper By A Journal

Reasons For The Rejection Of A Research Paper By A Journal

After years of research and months of drafting and formatting, a well-constructed research paper was completed. While no researcher wants to see their work remain unpublished, rejection is a common occurrence in scholarly publishing. It is, however, demotivating.

Acceptance of study on the first attempt is uncommon for researchers, and it is considerably more challenging for first-timers. However, Understanding why publishers reject manuscripts, on the other hand, can dramatically boost your chances of acceptance.

To be published in a high-quality, peer-reviewed journal, the author’s manuscript must contain characteristics that demonstrate it was well-thought-out or well-conceived, as well as well-reported research findings. Your research study was rejected for a reason, and the editors of the journal reject articles for good reasons.

In this article, we’ve discussed some common reasons for research papers being rejected by a suitable journal. If your research paper was rejected, ensure that you do not repeat these errors when submitting it to the next publication. If this is your first submission, take it through these basic criteria to ensure a minimal probability of rejection.

Generally, after submitting a paper to a journal, the editorial board reviews it before forwarding it to suggested review, and your paper is frequently rejected at this stage if the purpose of the research is unclear, the research question is not stated succinctly, the literature review is inappropriate, the methodology and study design are not stated thoroughly, and the results and discussion do not support the hypothesis.

Despite the fact that the suggested reviewer may reject your paper for technical reasons, these reasons are frequently related to the manner in which the research was conducted and, unlike editorial reasons, may require time to resolve or require the researcher to completely redo their research work.

List of some of the most often mentioned grounds for the rejection of research papers

Research Paper does not meet the journal objectives and scope

Each journal has a clearly defined mission and scope, which are available on the journal’s website. In general, early-career researchers overlook this part and submit articles to journals without assessing if their work adds value to the publication or its readers.

As such, before submitting your paper, it is prudent to become acquainted with the journal’s objective and scope. Indeed, a more successful technique is to compile a list of journals, starting with the one most relevant to the research you desire to publish.

Research Paper is written in unexplained writing

This can occur as a result of overuse of jargon or poor English. The research journals recommend that contributions be written in the most straightforward manner possible, ensuring that they are clearly accessible. Other factors, such as poor grammar, spelling problems, and the absence of important text elements such as affiliations, a list of authors, tables, and figures, frequently result in publishers dismissing papers without hesitation. If you have problems writing in English, there are numerous tools accessible to assist you in developing your research writing skills.

Research Paper violates the journal’s rules

Each journal has its own set of writing criteria that include citation style, typeface, font size, margin, and space. Failure to adhere to the journal’s writing requirements is typically the most common reason for the rejection of manuscripts by early-career academics. As a result, study the guidelines for the journal to which you wish to submit the essay thoroughly. Typesetting auto-formatting features can assist you in your endeavor.

Research Paper contains inadequate evidence

The data gathered during the investigation is insufficient to reach the conclusion stated in the research paper. This can occur when the sample size is insufficient or the control is poorly defined. If the data obtained does not support the paper’s hypothesis, rejection is a foregone conclusion.

Research Paper has uncertainty regarding the hypothesis

A hypothesis is a statement that a researcher makes in light of past research. The idea is then validated or refuted based on the results of the study. If a paper lacks a clear hypothesis or relies on one that has been examined and confirmed previously, journals nearly always reject it.

Research Paper contains inadequate Analysis

The final step of the research process is the statistical analysis of the acquired data and selecting an efficient statistical technique for analyzing the research data, on the other hand, can be difficult. Incorrect analysis and the application of an inefficient technique put doubt on the obtained results and the produced conclusions.

Research Paper does benefit the journal

Occasionally, publications find the conclusions of a study uninteresting, particularly if the findings offer no significant addition to the field’s advancement. If this is the case, it is almost probable that the work will be rejected.

Research Paper outcome is dubious

If a research paper’s conclusion is inconclusive or fails to address the hypothesis’s question, it is more likely to be rejected for this reason than for any other rejection.

Research Paper Violate ethical standards

Obtaining written consent from participants (if any), documenting that the research was conducted solely by one person and is not copied, and adhering to any associated ethical standards are essential. If a researcher does not follow any of these guidelines, her report will very probably be rejected for violating research ethics.

Finally, this article has established that the biggest reasons for research paper rejection, whether before or after it has been evaluated, are flaws with the research and issues with the writing/presentation of the study. A manuscript may be rejected if it contains inaccuracies in the research upon which it is based.

Note: Prior to submitting a research paper to a journal, it is necessary to carefully study and understand the journal’s author guidelines, as well as the journal’s aim, scope, ethical standards, and publication policy, in order to minimize the possibility of rejection.

This article closes with these points, you can now see the reasons for the journal’s rejection of your research paper. Hopefully, these reasons will assist you in structuring and formatting your article according to the journal’s criteria, minimizing the probability of future rejection. KRS is an academic cum research platform that assists you in your professional development by providing you with new articles on a regular basis, so stay connected.

If this is your first visit to our site, we encourage you to share and subscribe to our website in order to assist us in spreading the word. Visit our website for additional assistance with E-content and research, or contact us at [email protected] to schedule a complimentary consultation.

Leave a Reply